I Tested What AI Recommends in 19 Florida Cities
Last week I asked AI who to hire in three Southwest Florida cities (here’s that post). The results were interesting enough that I did what any reasonable person would do: I tested 16 more cities.
Same simple setup every time. I asked Google’s AI Mode, “Who’s the best [roofer / plumber / AC company] in [city]?” Then I pulled up Google Maps for the same search and compared the two. 19 cities, 7 trades, one very long afternoon.
Quick ground rules: I’m not naming businesses, because this isn’t a ranking and nobody needs that kind of morning. It’s one search per city from one spot, so think snapshot, not science fair. AI changes its mind a lot, so I’ll run it again.
The short version
- AI gave me about 7 names per search. That’s it. Seven seats at the table.
- It skipped more than 178 businesses with 4.7+ stars and 40+ reviews. Great companies, just not invited.
- In 14 of 19 searches, it left out at least one company from the top five on Google Maps.
Here’s the takeaway in plain English: having great reviews gets you in the building. It doesn’t get you on stage.
Three ways AI picks who to recommend
1. Sometimes it just copies Google Maps. In St. Petersburg, Fort Myers and Cape Coral, AI mostly named whoever was already on top in Maps. If that’s your market, good news: the work you do for Maps pays you twice.
2. Sometimes reviews are the bouncer. In Jacksonville, every HVAC company AI named had over 2,000 Google reviews. In Cape Coral, it named exactly the landscapers with 100 or more. Under the line? Didn’t matter how good your rating was. Not on the list.
3. And sometimes it does its own thing entirely. In Fort Lauderdale, AI’s top roofer wasn’t even in the top 20 on Maps. In Melbourne, it picked the plumber ranked #18 and skipped #3, who has over 2,500 reviews. And in Port St. Lucie, it passed on both big national pest control brands and went all local. Somewhere a national marketing team is very confused.
All 19 searches
| City | Trade | AI named | Highly rated companies AI skipped |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tampa | HVAC | 7 | 15 |
| St. Petersburg | Plumbing | 8 | 10+ |
| Clearwater | Electrical | 6 | 8+ |
| Sarasota | AC repair | 7 | 7+ |
| Bradenton | Roofing | 7 | 11+ |
| Port Charlotte | Pest control | 6 | 10+ |
| Venice | Pool service | 6 | 7+ |
| Orlando | AC repair | 6 | 9+ |
| Miami | Plumbing | 8 | 12 |
| Fort Lauderdale | Roofing | 7 | 7 |
| West Palm Beach | Pest control | 6 | 11 |
| Jacksonville | HVAC | 7 | 15 |
| Fort Myers | Electrical | 8 | 7 |
| Naples | Pool service | 7 | 7 |
| Cape Coral | Landscaping | 6 | 3 |
| Pensacola | Roofing | 5 | 9 |
| Tallahassee | HVAC | 7 | 12 |
| Melbourne | Plumbing | 7 | 6 |
| Port St. Lucie | Pest control | 6 | 12 |
So what do you actually do with this?
First, know that ranking on Google Maps and getting recommended by AI are now two different jobs. You can be crushing one and invisible in the other.
Second, reviews matter, but they’re not magic. Companies with over 1,000 reviews still got skipped in Sarasota, Melbourne and Port St. Lucie.
What the picked companies have in common is that they’re easy to understand. AI is basically a very fast, very literal new customer. If it can quickly tell what you do, where you do it and that people like you, you’re in the running. That usually comes down to three things:
- A Google Business Profile that’s fully filled out, not half done from 2019
- A clear page on your website for each service and each area you cover
- The same name, address and phone number everywhere you’re listed
No tricks, no secret sauce, and anyone promising they can guarantee an AI recommendation is selling you something. But all of this is in your control, which is the good news.
Want the full data?
I put every search, how I ran it and the patterns into the Florida AI Visibility Index on Scalesior, the marketing company I run. Free to use, just link back. And if you want to know where your business stands, grab a free audit and I’ll run the test for your city and trade.
[…] Want me to check for you? I’ll run your searches, show you what AI says about your business, and tell you the first three things I’d fix. Book a free AI Visibility Audit. You can also see the full Monday results in the Florida AI Visibility Index and my write-up of the 19-city test. […]